It looks like Kim du Toit’s been adding gunpowder to his Wheaties today. I’ve been watching the sturm und drang over the libertarian question on his site as well as that of Mrs. du Toit. I think the primary problem is that even most libertarians don’t know what it is. There are a bunch of different subgroups who all claim that title for themselves. To make things more fun, you also have the Libertarian Party to deal with. I think Kim’s characterization of libertarianism as simply “anarcho-capitalism” is off the mark, but then they’re the ones that seem to get all the attention.
Over the years I’ve played with a variety of forms of libertarianism. There are some things that are appealing about anarcho-capitalism, but I just don’t see how it can be made to work. Heck, the market can’t even restrain those damn vermin telemarketers. That was one of the things that convinced me that a completely unregulated market was going too far. But at the same time, I would like to see a lot of other regulations go away. Government is a cure that is often worse than the disease, given the law of unintended consequences. We must be careful of how we apply it and avoid using it willy-nilly for petty little things.
I think the final straw for me, though, was 9/11. I’ve always been a supporter of a strong national defense, although I’ve been somewhat wary of some of the decisions that have been made in that arena (9mm pistols, V-22 Osprey, etc). I’m in favor of any action that will make the United States safer at home, but I don’t ever want to see us trying to gain an empire. All I want is to be left alone to live my life in peace.
So, I now find myself without a political home. I find almost everything the Democrats stand for repugnant to my beliefs. The Republican party has potential, but they tend to shoot themselves in the foot trying to out-socialist the Democrats (and don’t get me started on their religious fundamentalist fringe). The Libertarian party lost me with their stand on the war. The Greens are a bunch of socialist nutbags (green on the outside, red on the inside).
In many ways, I think I’m a constitutionalist. I’d like to see us uphold the Constitution as the Law Of The Land. I don’t want to get too deep into this, but I’ve often wished we could bring back a few of the founders to examine our current federal government. I’m sure they wouldn’t have much use for the DEA or BATF or any of the other alphabet soup agencies that plague our country (although I suspect that they would take one look at our government and run screaming from the room). Having said that, though, I’m not interested in the Constitution Party either. They’re just as bad as the others in using the government to regulate every aspect of the lives of other people.
Maybe I need to start a “Leave Me The Hell Alone” party.
Update: I’ll probably take Kim up on his quest to get everyone to buy just one more gun this year, though, even if he doesn’t like libertarians.
But then, I’ve always had a soft spot for all those sad little guns I see at the gun show with no one to take them home. It’s such a shame that so many of them don’t have good homes with owners who will take care of them.